REDCap e-Consent Framework vs Signant SmartSignals eConsent(eConsent)

Sponsors, CROs, research sites and academic teams choosing eConsent software for clinical trials and research studies.

Scope Electronic informed consent (eConsent) software that presents, explains, signs and version-controls participant consent for clinical trials and research studies, remote or on site, as sponsors, CROs, sites and academic research teams would shortlist it.

Guide updated How we compare

Compare within eConsent

Study fit, side by side

These notes describe the products in the eConsent guide.

REDCap e-Consent Framework

Best for
Academic and non-profit teams that already use REDCap and can validate it themselves
What to consider
REDCap's e-Consent Framework is free to non-profit consortium members and sits inside the EDC they already use, at 8,526 institutions in 167 countries. It is a framework rather than a full eConsent product, and Part 11 compliance depends on how each host validates it. For-profit sponsors cannot license it.
Read product profile

Signant SmartSignals eConsent

Best for
Sponsors that want PDF or fully interactive eConsent inside a wider eCOA, EDC and RTSM suite
What to consider
Signant offers PDF-based and interactive eConsent with assent workflows, comprehension tests, multimedia and in-solution translation management, as an EDC add-on or standalone. It cites 'hundreds of protocols' but publishes no exact eConsent counts or prices.
Read product profile

Compare the features

Both products use the same category definitions. Product order is editorial; products are not ranked.

Full eConsent feature comparison

Single and double checks describe documented support for an individual feature. Double checks use the extended definition for that feature. Unknown means the available evidence does not establish support.

Expand a feature definition or support note for context and its original source.

REDCap e-Consent Framework vs Signant SmartSignals eConsent (eConsent): category feature evidence and sources. Products are not ranked.
Category featureREDCap e-Consent FrameworkSignant SmartSignals eConsent
Consent experience and comprehension
Feature definitions
Supported
A digital consent presentation or completion workflow is documented.
Extended support
Digital consent includes both multimedia content and participant comprehension checks.
Supported

Consent built as REDCap surveys with an end-of-survey certification step, PDF archival and version footer; the framework is not a full eConsent process on its own.

Source
About this support label

Survey certification, archival and versioning provide a consent framework; it is not a full consent process alone.

Extended support

Assent workflow, built-in comprehension Q&A, rich multimedia, content flagging, remote consent and re-consent with automated version control.

Source
About this support label

Consent combines rich multimedia with built-in comprehension questions.

Compliance and regulatory track record
Feature definitions
Supported
Relevant trial or security controls are stated.
Extended support
Relevant trial controls plus a public ISO/SOC certificate or audit report are documented; a certification claim or logo alone is insufficient.
Supported

REDCap can be used in compliance with Part 11, HIPAA and GDPR, but validation depends on the hosting institution.

Source
About this support label

Compliance is conditional on validation by the hosting institution.

Supported

Regulatory-compliant, traceable audit trails and experience implementing eConsent for 'hundreds of protocols'; no exact counts.

Source
Global scale and languages
Feature definitions
Supported
Multicountry use or multilingual/localized participant support is documented.
Extended support
Both multicountry use and multilingual/localized participant support are documented.
Extended support

8,526 institutions in 167 countries; Multi-Language Management lets teams translate forms and the participant interface.

Source
About this support label

Multicountry institutional use and translation of forms and participant interfaces are documented.

Extended support

Multi-language support with translation management; a published case study ran in 6 countries and 8 languages.

Source
About this support label

Translation management and a multicountry, multilingual case study are documented.

Integrations and suite fit
Feature definitions
Supported
A connection to another research system or an API is documented.
Extended support
Native EDC or eCOA integration plus an API or integration with other research systems is documented.
Extended support

Consent lives inside REDCap, a full EDC with an API.

Source
About this support label

Consent is part of REDCap EDC, which also provides an API.

Extended support

Embedded add-on to Signant's EDC with single logon, plus eClinical integration and SSO with site and sponsor systems.

Source
About this support label

The EDC add-on also integrates with site and sponsor systems through eClinical integration and SSO.

Time to launch and self-service build
Feature definitions
Supported
A study build process, self-service builder or launch timeframe is documented.
Extended support
Study teams can configure the study themselves, with a stated build or launch timeframe.
Supported

Research teams build consent instruments themselves, often from institutional templates; turnaround depends on the host.

Source
About this support label

Research teams build consent instruments; turnaround depends on the host.

Supported

Self-service implementation with template libraries and Word import, or full service; no turnaround times published.

Source
About this support label

Self-service templates and Word import are documented; turnaround times are not published.

Published pricing and terms
Feature definitions
Supported
A production pricing basis, model or contract terms beyond a sales contact are published.
Extended support
Numerical production prices or a free production option with its conditions are published.
Extended support

Software and consortium support are free to non-profit organizations that join; not licensed to for-profit organizations.

Source
About this support label

Software and consortium support are free for participating nonprofit organizations; for-profit licensing is excluded.

Supported

No prices; a 2021 release names Silver, Gold and Platinum license tiers.

Source
About this support label

The current note documents named license tiers but no prices.

The guide update date reflects guide edits. Vendor statements are attributed in the evidence.

Keep the category in view

Compare these products with the other tools in the eConsent guide using the same feature definitions.

More eConsent comparisons featuring one of these products.