Research teams, sponsors and CROs comparing data collection for clinical trials, from focused participant-centered studies to complex multi-site protocols.
Scope Dedicated EDC systems and participant-centered clinical-trial data collection are compared by their documented capabilities. Whether a participant-centered platform also needs a dedicated EDC depends on in-visit data entry, clinical queries, coding, verification and database-management requirements, rather than study size or trial phase alone.
These notes describe the products in the EDC guide.
REDCap
Best for
Academic and non-profit teams running investigator-initiated studies, as a free baseline.
What to consider
REDCap is the free academic baseline, with open data standards and very wide adoption. It comes without vendor support, its Part 11 status depends on each institution, and sponsors and CROs cannot license it.
Clinical trials and research studies that need participant-data collection and ongoing engagement, with consent, forms, ePRO, follow-up and connections to existing systems
What to consider
WeGuide brings participant-data collection and ongoing engagement into one study program for clinical trials and research studies. Teams can run screening, consent, forms, ePRO, reminders and follow-up in a branded participant app. The Integration Engine connects existing research systems when required. If the protocol needs intensive site-entered clinical data, complex queries, medical coding or advanced database management, use an appropriate EDC alongside the participant workflow. Suitability depends on those requirements, rather than study size or phase alone.
Less suitable for
Protocols requiring extensive in-visit eCRFs, complex data queries, medical coding, source-data verification or an enterprise database-lock workflow.
Single and double checks describe documented support for an individual feature. Double checks use the extended definition for that feature. Unknown means the available evidence does not establish support.
Expand a feature definition or support note for context and its original source.
REDCap vs WeGuide (EDC): category feature evidence and sources. Products are not ranked.
Category feature
REDCap
WeGuide
Track record in regulated multi-site trialsFeature definitions
Supported
Published product or wider-platform adoption, or a named clinical-research deployment.
Extended support
Product-specific study, customer, institution, site or participant figures plus a published country count establish international use.
REDCap
Extended support
The REDCap Consortium lists 8,526 institutions in 167 countries and 2.9M projects, but REDCap is licensed to non-profits and its use is concentrated in academic research.
The consortium reports institution and project adoption across a stated country count.
WeGuide
Supported
Public research examples include BRACE and INHERIT. These document research use of the participant platform, rather than counts of full enterprise EDC deployments or regulatory submissions.
Self-build and approval of production changes are stated; uninterrupted changes are not established.
WeGuide
Supported
Study teams configure forms, question types, conditional logic, input validation and testing. This supports focused trial data collection; uninterrupted enterprise-EDC database amendments are not established by the public material.
Study configuration is documented; a no-interruption EDC amendment workflow is not.
Compliance and securityFeature definitions
Supported
Relevant trial compliance or security controls are stated, with their scope identified.
Extended support
Relevant trial controls and a publicly accessible ISO certificate or SOC audit report covering the product or vendor are documented.
REDCap
Supported
Vanderbilt says REDCap can be installed for 21 CFR Part 11 compliance, but this depends on each institution's setup; Penn Medicine, for example, states its REDCap is not Part 11-compliant.
Part 11 support depends on institutional setup; the note also identifies a non-compliant host.
WeGuide
Supported
WeGuide states ISO 27001:2022 certification and support for GDPR, HIPAA and 21 CFR Part 11. The public material does not provide the certificate or an audit report.
Randomization, eConsent and surveys establish base support despite the stated absence of supply, coding and CTMS.
WeGuide
Supported
Study programs combine participant forms, ePRO, consent and follow-up. REDCap and other EDC connections can be configured where additional clinical-data workflows require them. A native enterprise EDC, medical-coding and supply-management suite is not claimed.