MyDataHelps (CareEvolution) vs REDCap(Registries)

Research teams running patient registries and long-term cohort studies that collect data reported by participants themselves.

Guide updated How we compare

Compare within Registries

Study fit, side by side

These notes describe the products in the Registries guide.

MyDataHelps (CareEvolution)

Best for
US academic cohorts that want participants sharing surveys, EHR and claims data in one self-service app
What to consider
CareEvolution cites NIH's All of Us Research Program, which uses a white-label version of the app, and the Framingham Heart Study among MyDataHelps users. Researchers can schedule SMS, email and push notifications, education content, returned results and eGift card rewards, with a validated instrument library, automatically versioned screening and eConsent, and EHR and claims data. Its security evidence is a NIST 800-53 assessment and an NIH Authority to Operate rather than ISO 27001 or SOC 2, and its only public pricing term is a free Designer account.
Read product profile

REDCap

Best for
Academic and nonprofit registries whose institution already hosts REDCap
What to consider
REDCap is free for nonprofit members of its consortium, and its MyCap app gives participants a free native iOS and Android app with offline entry, in-app messaging and announcements, though MyCap cannot yet remind participants about incomplete tasks. Its instrument library includes PROMIS computerized adaptive tests, e-Consent keeps versioned consent forms, and REDCap can pull EHR data over FHIR. The hosting institution sets up compliance and security, so there is no vendor-level certification.
Read product profile

Compare the features

Both products use the same category definitions. Product order is editorial; products are not ranked.

Full Registries feature comparison

Single and double checks describe documented support for an individual feature. Double checks use the extended definition for that feature. Unknown means the available evidence does not establish support.

Expand a feature definition or support note for context and its original source.

MyDataHelps (CareEvolution) vs REDCap (Registries): category feature evidence and sources. Products are not ranked.
Category featureMyDataHelps (CareEvolution)REDCap
Participant app and retention
Feature definitions
Supported
A participant-facing app or web interface is documented.
Extended support
The participant software includes automated notifications plus messaging, education content or returned results.
Extended support

The MyDataHelps app with scheduled SMS, email or push notifications, education resources, returned results and eGift card rewards.

Source
About this support label

The app combines scheduled notifications with education, returned results and rewards.

Extended support

MyCap is a free native iOS and Android app with offline entry, due-day task alerts, in-app messaging and announcements; it cannot yet send reminders for incomplete tasks.

Source
About this support label

MyCap has due-day alerts and in-app messaging; it cannot remind participants about incomplete tasks.

Long-term follow-up and PRO instruments
Feature definitions
Supported
Longitudinal follow-up or patient-reported outcome collection is documented.
Extended support
A validated PRO instrument library plus automated follow-up scheduling are documented.
Supported

A library of validated instruments and NIH common data elements, with custom delivery schedules.

Source
About this support label

A validated library and custom delivery schedules are documented; automated follow-up is not explicit.

Extended support

A library of validated instruments including PROMIS and Neuro-QoL computerized adaptive tests, with automatic survey invitations for follow-up.

Source
About this support label

Validated PRO instruments are paired with automatic follow-up survey invitations.

Remote enrolment and eConsent
Feature definitions
Supported
An electronic participant consent workflow is documented.
Extended support
Consent versioning or re-consent is paired with participant self-enrollment or eligibility screening.
Extended support

Recruitment by shareable QR code or invitation, participant-facing eligibility checks, and automatically versioned screening surveys and eConsent.

Source
About this support label

Participant eligibility checks are paired with automatically versioned eConsent.

Supported

e-Consent surveys can be opened from a public survey link or QR code, and each consent form has version control.

Source
About this support label

Public consent links and versioning are documented; self-enrollment or eligibility screening is not established.

Data linkage and export
Feature definitions
Supported
Data exchange through an API, import/export or an external data source is documented.
Extended support
An API plus EHR linkage or a named interoperability standard is documented.
Extended support

APIs and SDKs, a REDCap-integrated survey builder, and EHR and claims data from over 1.5 million providers, standardized to common code systems.

Source
About this support label

APIs and SDKs are paired with EHR and claims linkage.

Extended support

REDCap pulls structured EHR data into projects through a FHIR web service (Clinical Data Interoperability Services), alongside the REDCap API; EHR access depends on the hosting institution.

Source
About this support label

The API is paired with FHIR-based EHR pulls, subject to hosting-institution access.

Compliance and security
Feature definitions
Supported
Relevant trial or security controls are stated.
Extended support
Relevant trial controls plus a public ISO/SOC certificate or audit report are documented; a certification claim or logo alone is insufficient.
Supported

States HIPAA and FDA Part 11 compliance and NIST 800-53 controls assessed by a FedRAMP-accredited assessor, with an NIH Authority to Operate, but names no ISO 27001 or SOC 2 certification.

Source
About this support label

Trial controls and a NIST assessment are stated; public ISO/SOC certificate or report evidence is not established.

Supported

REDCap can be installed in compliance with HIPAA and 21 CFR Part 11, but compliance depends on each hosting institution and there is no vendor certification.

Source
About this support label

Compliance depends on the hosting institution; there is no vendor certification.

Published pricing and terms
Feature definitions
Supported
A production pricing basis, model or contract terms beyond a sales contact are published.
Extended support
Numerical production prices or a free production option with its conditions are published.
Unknown

A free Designer account to build and explore a study for as long as needed; no pricing basis, prices or terms for running a study are published.

Source
About this support label

A free Designer account does not establish production pricing or a free production option.

Unknown does not mean unavailable. The public evidence does not establish support under this category’s definition.

Extended support

The REDCap license is free for nonprofit consortium members, who host it themselves, and MyCap is free; for-profit teams must use paid hosting.

Source
About this support label

Nonprofit consortium members have a free, self-hosted license and free MyCap; for-profit teams require paid hosting.

The guide update date reflects guide edits. Vendor statements are attributed in the evidence.

Keep the category in view

Compare these products with the other tools in the Registries guide using the same feature definitions.

More Registries comparisons featuring one of these products.